Bold Predictions
I asked my friends and colleagues Tom, Sam, and Maria for some bold predictions ahead of the first round, and even came up with three of my own to see how good our crystal-ball-staring is.Tom
1. The Miami Dolphins go OT before QB
2. Tua Tagovailoa falls outside the top 20
3. Four OTs are taken in the top 10 picks
- Unfortunately for Tom, a Dolphins fan, none of his predictions came true, although the 'Fins were able to get Tua Tagovailoa, Austin Jackson, and Noah Igbinoghene, as well as trading back to pick up more draft capital.
Sam
1. The Miami Dolphins don't take a QB in the top 10
2. The Philadelphia Eagles trade up to draft a WR
3. Jacksonville Jaguars go QB in the first round
- Sam almost got prediction number two correct as the Eagles selected WR Jalen Reagor 21st overall, but they didn't have to trade up to do it. Meanwhile, the Dolphins took Tua fifth overall, and the Jags decided to bolster their defense, selecting both CB CJ Henderson, and DE K'Lavon Chaisson.
Maria
1. Cam Akers is the first RB off the board in the first round
2. The Indianapolis Colts take Jordan Love with the 27th overall pick
3. Tua Tagovailoa drops outside the top 15
- Maria's claim that Cam Akers would be the first RB off the board surprised me, as it was widely considered that D'Andre Swift would be the first gone, and she was nearly right, but instead of Akers, the Kansas City Chiefs selected Clyde Edwards-Helaire with the final pick of the round. Meanwhile, it was the Green Bay Packers selecting Love with the 27th pick.
Calum
1. The Chicago Bears trade into the first round to take Jordan Love
2. At least 5 draft-day trades go down
3. The most selected position in the first round will be cornerback
- Well I have to admit, I didn't see that NFC North team trading up for Jordan Love. So close, but yet so far. There were just four trades on draft day, as the teams in the top 10 all held on to their selections. As for the most-selected position, that was a three-way tie between cornerback, offensive tackle, and wide receiver.
Head vs. Heart
I also asked these three to give me head and heart selections for their teams in the first round. Who did they think they would pick (head), and who did they want them to pick (heart)? Let's see how everyone got on:Tom
Head says:
QB Justin Herbert 5th OverallOT Mekhi Becton 18th Overall
RB D'Andre Swift 26th Overall
Heart says:
QB Tua Tagovailoa 5th Overall
OT Mekhi Becton 18th Overall
RB D'Andre Swift 26th Overall
Actual Selections:
QB Tua Tagovailoa 5th Overall
OT Austin Jackson 18th Overall
CB Noah Igbinoghene 30th Overall (trade with Green Bay)
Sam
Head says:
OT Josh Jones 22nd Overall
CB Kristian Fulton 25th Overall
Heart says:
DT Javon Kinlaw 22nd Overall
CB CJ Henderson 25th Overall
Actual Selections:
WR Justin Jefferson 22nd Overall
CB Jeff Gladney 31st Overall (trade with San Francisco)
Maria
Head says:
QB Jordan Love or QB Jalen Hurts
Heart says:
LB Patrick Queen
Actual Selection:
C Cesar Ruiz
Calum
Head says:
DE AJ Epenesa or DE Yetur Gross-Matos
Heart says:
LB Kenneth Murray or LB Patrick Queen
Actual Selection:
LB Patrick Queen
The Awards
Best Value Pick
CeeDee Lamb to the Dallas Cowboys, 17th Overall
Jerry Jones didn't need another wide receiver, but when the electric Lamb fell into his lap at number 17, he couldn't miss. After posting career numbers last year, Das Prescott now gets an immediate upgrade at wide receiver to go alongside Amari Cooper and Michael Gallup, which will cause no end of matchup nightmares for the other teams in the NFC East. If the Cowboys can fill the holes needed on defense on Friday night, then it could be a very fruitful draft for America's Team
Biggest Reach
CB Damon Arnette to the Las Vegas Raiders, 19th Overall
How surprising was this pick? Well, let's put it this way, none of the NFL social media accounts had a post ready for Damon Arnette. On the live broadcast, both Mel Kiper and Daniel Jeremiah said they had him down as a round 2/3 talent, so seeing him come off the board before the likes of Jeff Gladney, Trevon Diggs, and other highly-touted CBs was a very surprising move, although it's exactly the kind of move that we've come to expect from the Raiders.
Most Surprising Pick
QB Jordan Love to the Green Bay Packers, 26th Overall
When you have a first-ballot Hall of Famer at QB, and you haven't spent a first round draft pick on an offensive skill position player in nigh-on 15 years, you should probably think about bolstering the WR corps or the running back position. Instead, the Packers traded up four spots to take Jordan Love. I can see the logic behind the pick, as Aaron Rodgers sat behind Brett Favre before becoming a legend, but this team made it to the NFC Championship Game last season. Why not spend big on improving the offense, and try to take that final step to the promised land, rather than picking the only player who will both annoy your QB, and not see any playing time in his first season?
Best First Round
Denver Broncos (WR Jerry Jeudy, 15th Overall)
In their wildest dreams, I'm not sure that the Denver Broncos could have envisaged themselves picking up arguably the best receiver in the draft in the middle of the first round, let alone having the choice between the top two. Jeudy is one of the most polished route runners that many draft experts have seen in years, and draws favourable comparisons to some of the league's top names already. Now, Vic Fangio gets the chance to pair the Alabama product with one of the most dependable young receivers in the game as Jeudy will start opposite Courtland Sutton on opening day, which will be music to the ears of presumptive QB Drew Lock.
Worst First Round
New York Giants (OT Andrew Thomas, 4th Overall)
I didn't just want to rinse and repeat my breakdown of the Raiders' pick of Damon Arnette, so instead I've gone for the Giants, whose selection of Andrew Thomas baffled many on draft night. The Georgia product was considered the fourth-best option at OT behind Tristan Wirfs, Jedrick Wills, and Mekhi Becton, all of whom are projected to have higher ceilings at the next level. So with the top three tackles on the board, as well as a plug-and-play versatile impact player like Isaiah Simmons, the Giants decided to shock everyone by picking Thomas, who they could easily have traded back about ten spots to select if they had wanted to.